Published on 01/01/2024
New Year, New Questions
By Carsten Haese, Nathan Long, and Justin Hovdenes
This Article from: Carsten Haese
Cranial Translation
Deutsch
Español
Français
We hope you were careful
with your fireworks.
with your fireworks.
Anyway, the beginning of the year is a time to make resolutions for the new year, and our new year's resolution is to keep answering your rules questions. You can help us by continuing to send in your questions, which you can email to moko@cranialinsertion.com or tweet to @CranialTweet. One of our authors will send you a reply, and your question might appear in a future article!
Q: If I control Unbound Flourishing and activate Wizard's Rockets, does Unbound Flourishing double the amount of mana I get from the Rockets?
A: No. While activating Wizard's Rockets' ability triggers Unbound Flourishing's triggered ability, the resolution of that triggered ability does nothing. To copy an ability, you make a copy of an object on the stack. Since mana abilities don't use the stack, there is nothing to copy in the first place.
Q: I play Wrath of God and my opponent used Momentary Blink on their only creature. Does it survive the Wrath of God?
A: It does not. Blinking the creature exiles it and returns it to the battlefield as a new creature, so it resets its identity, but this would only matter to a spell that targets it. Wrath of God doesn't target anything or otherwise "lock in" what it will destroy. It simply destroys all creatures that are on the battlefield at the time it resolves, which includes your opponent's newly returned creature.
Q: Let's say I control Mayael's Aria, Mossbridge Troll, and five 1/1 creature tokens. Mayael's Aria triggers and its first part puts +1/+1 counters on the Troll and the five tokens. Can I activate the Troll's ability before the third part resolves so I then win the game?
A: No, that doesn't work. Mayael's Aria has one triggered ability that goes on the stack as a whole. When the ability resolves, you follow all its instructions in order, and nobody gets priority to activate any other abilities in between those instructions. After you put the +1/+1 counters on your creatures, you don't gain 10 life because you don't control a creature with power 10 or greater, and you don't win the game because you don't control a creature with power 20 or greater.
Q: How does Deflecting Palm work? If I'm being attacked by ten white 4/4 Angel tokens, can I choose "white" or "Angel" as the source of damage?
A: No, a source of damage is a single object, so you can choose one of the Angels as the source whose damage to deflect, but the other nine Angels will still give you a righteous beating.
Q: Let's say I'm getting attacked by two 10/10 creatures with infect, and I Deflecting Palm the damage from one of them to my opponent. Do we both die from poison counters?
A: No. The 10/10 that goes through to you deals ten poison counters to you, while the damage from the other 10/10 is prevented, and Deflecting Palm deals 10 damage to your opponent. Since Deflecting Palm deals that damage itself and it doesn't have infect, your opponent simply loses 10 life. If your opponent had 10 or less life before all this, both of you lose the game at the same time and the game is a draw, but otherwise your opponent wins the game.
Q: Does reconfigure count as an equip ability for Fervent Champion?
A: No, only abilities with the keyword "equip" in them are equip abilities. Reconfigure does something very similar, but it's different enough to not be an equip ability.
Q: My opponent has cursed me with Overwhelming Splendor. If I cast Serra's Emissary and choose enchantment for it, what happens?
A: Not much happens. You'll have a 1/1 Serra's Emissary that has no abilities. Since it has no abilities, you don't have protection from enchantments, so Overwhelming Splendor remains attached to you. Also note that you don't even get to choose a card type for Serra's Emissary at all. As Serra's Emissary enters the battlefield, the game takes into account that the Emissary won't have the ability that asks you to choose a card type, so this replacement effect doesn't apply and the Emissary enters without a chosen card type. This means that even if you subsequently get rid of Overwhelming Splendor somehow, Serra's Emissary still won't give you protection from anything.
Please drink responsibly
A: Nope. When a transforming double-faced card transforms, it doesn't leave and re-enter the battlefield. It stays the same permanent, just with different characteristics. If Thing in the Ice didn't have summoning sickness anymore, then neither does Awoken Horror.
Q: If I cast Cursed Mirror and have it copy my opponent's Zacama, Primal Calamity, do I get to untap my lands?
A: Yes! Cursed Mirror acquires all abilities of Zacama, Primal Calamity, including its enter-the-battlefield ability. When that ability triggers, it checks whether you cast the creature that is now Zacama, Primal Calamity. You did cast the Cursed Mirror, so the condition is fulfilled even though you didn't cast a spell named Zacama, Primal Calamity.
Q: If I copy Fiery Emancipation's ability with Lithoform Engine, does the source deal six times normal damage, or nine times normal damage?
A: Well, first off, you can't copy this ability with Lithoform Engine. The ability is neither a triggered ability nor an activated ability. It's a static ability that creates a replacement effect. You could copy the spell Fiery Emancipation when you originally cast it, which would give you a second Fiery Emancipation in the form of a token, but you'd have to be able to come up with the 10 mana to do that all in the same turn. If you do control two Fiery Emancipations, either by having copied the spell with Lithoform Engine, or copying the enchantment with Copy Enchantment, or even just by casting a second Fiery Emancipation, then you have two replacement effects that each multiply damage times three. Both effects get to apply, and the second effect triples the result from the first effect, so in the end the damage will be multiplied by nine.
Q: I control Goro-Goro and Satoru and manage to deal combat damage to three different players with creatures that entered the battlefield this turn. How many Dragon Spirit tokens do I create?
A: You create three tokens. Goro-Goro and Satoru's ability looks for the event "one or more creatures you control that entered the battlefield this turn deal combat damage to a player", which means you get one trigger for each player that is dealt damage by one or more such creatures.
Q: I control a 5/5 that was dealt 3 damage this turn, and I activate Huatli, the Sun's Heart's ability. Do I gain 5 life or 2 life?
A: Assuming that the creature was just dealt regular damage, i.e. not something like wither or infect that is dealt in the form of -1/-1 counters, the damage does not reduce the creature's toughness. The creature is a 5/5 that has 3 damage marked on it, so its toughness is still 5, and you gain 5 life with Huatli's ability.
Q: My opponent controls five lands and Land Equilibrium and I control four lands. If I play Skyshroud Claim, do I have to sacrifice one of my lands?
A: No, you'll be at six lands. Land Equilibrium creates a replacement effect that changes how your lands enter the battlefield, but only if you control at least as many lands as your opponent. Both Forests from Skyshroud Claim enter the battlefield at the same time, and at that time the condition for Land Equilibrium's replacement effect is not true, so the effect doesn't apply to either of the two lands, so both lands enter the battlefield normally.
Q: Can I cast a sorcery for its madness cost during my opponent's turn?
A: If something causes you to discard it during your opponent's turn, sure. Discarding it triggers a triggered ability that gives you the option of casting it for its madness cost, and since it's not giving a duration for this permission, it means "right now, during the resolution of this triggered ability," which is a time at which you normally couldn't even cast an instant because you don't have priority at that time. The only thing that normally keeps you from casting a sorcery during your opponent's turn is that normally there is nothing giving you permission to do so. Madness gives you this permission, so you can cast the sorcery at that time.
We wish you a safe and
happy new year!
happy new year!
A: You've been told correctly. Doubling Season only applies if an effect puts counters on a permanent, while Lae'zel applies if you put counters on something. Adding loyalty counters to a planeswalker to activate its ability is a cost, and costs are not effects, so Doubling Season doesn't apply to it. Amusingly enough, though, if you control both Lae'zel and Doubling Season, they will both apply. This is because Lae'zel's replacement effect changes the number of counters, so Doubling Season recognizes that the counters are being put on by an effect in that scenario.
Q: In the Runestone Caverns room of Dungeon of the Mad Mage, do I have to play the exiled cards immediately, or can I wait to play them later?
A: This is very similar to the madness question from above. Since the ability does not specify a duration for the "you may play them" effect, it means "right now". If you can't or don't want to play those cards at that time, they'll remain exiled indefinitely.
Q: If I control The Millennium Calendar and Basalt Monolith, can I repeatedly tap and untap Basalt Monolith to put a bunch of time counters on the Calendar?
A: No, that doesn't work. The Millenium Calendar only gets time counters with its first ability when you untap one or more permanents during your untap step. You don't get priority in the untap step, so you can't activate Basalt Monolith's ability at that time. By the time you get priority to tap and untap the Basalt Monolith, the game is in the upkeep step, and The Millenium Calendar is not interested in permanents being untapped during the upkeep step.
Q: My opponent controls Horobi, Death's Wail and targets my Bear Cub with some spell. Can I redirect the spell to my Spellskite to save the Bear Cub?
A: No, and this play actually ends up getting the Spellskite killed as well. By the time you activate Spellskite's ability, Horobi's ability has already triggered for the Bear Cub, and changing the spell to target something else doesn't untrigger or counter Horobi's ability. The only thing you're accomplishing is that Horobi's ability triggers again when Spellskite becomes the target of the spell, so both the Spellskite and the Bear Cub end up getting destroyed.
Q: If I control Mirrorworks and cast Sol Ring, can I tap the Sol Ring itself to make a copy if it with Mirrorworks?
A: Yes, you can do that. By the time Mirrorworks' ability resolves and asks you if you want to pay
, the Sol Ring is on the battlefield and it doesn't have summoning sickness, so you can tap it for to make use of Mirrorworks' ability. And that's all the time we have for today's episode. Thanks for reading, and please come back next week for more Magic rules Q&A. Happy new year!
- Carsten Haese
About the Author:
Carsten Haese is a former Level 2 judge based in Toledo, OH. He is retired from active judging, but he still writes for Cranial Insertion and helps organize an annual charity Magic tournament that benefits the National MS Society.
No comments yet.
